Metabolism estimates in small boreal lakes: the importance of accounting for vertical fluxes of oxygen

Abstract:

Lake metabolism models based on the diel oxygen technique often assume that oxygen dynamics are mainly controlled by metabolic processes, only accounting for wind-driven atmospheric gas exchange. However, oxygen dynamics can also be affected by abiotic mass fluxes across oxygen gradients within lakes and atmospheric gas exchange driven by convection. Here, we quantify how much vertical fluxes of oxygen modify epilimnetic metabolism estimates for three pairs of small Swedish boreal lakes, one of each fertilized with nitrate, with dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations of 7 to 22 mg l^-1. Oxygen concentrations were measured every 10 min at 50 cm depth and biweekly across depths profiles during one full open water period. Based on additional two weeks of ten-minute oxygen profiling we calculated vertical fluxes of oxygen using equations for atmospheric gas exchange caused by wind shear (F1) and convection (F2), and lake-internal gas exchange caused by diffusion and mixed layer deepening (F3). We ran three inverse Bayesian models to estimate daily metabolism: (M1) accounting for F1, (M2) accounting for F1 and F2, and (M3) accounting for F1 and F3. Initial results suggest that gross primary production (GPP), ecosystem respiration (ER) and net ecosystem production (NEP) ranged from 0.1 to 0.2, -0.3 to -0.5 and -0.2 to -0.4 g C m^-2 d^-1, respectively. GPP and R were higher in fertilized lakes and at the lower end of previous worldwide estimates. Accounting for convection-driven gas exchange increased ER estimates by 10-40% (M2 vs. M1). This bias increased with DOC concentration but was not affected by fertilization. Including lake-internal vertical oxygen fluxes changed GPP and ER estimates by up to ±40% (M3 vs. M1), with inconsistent trends along the DOC-gradient. We conclude that vertical fluxes of oxygen can significantly affect diel oxygen dynamics in oligotrophic humic systems and should therefore be included in metabolism models applied to small boreal lakes.