Bulk rheology and simulated episodic tremor and slip within a numerically-modeled block-dominated subduction melange

Abstract:

We investigate the influence of melange rheology in a subduction thrust interface on stress and slip cycling constrained by observations from an exhumed subduction complex at Chrystalls Beach, New Zealand. A two-phase mélange dominated by large, competent brittle-viscous blocks surrounded by a weak non-linear viscous matrix is numerically modeled, and the evolution of bulk stress are analysed as the domain deforms. The models produce stress cycling behaviour under constant shear strain rate boundary conditions for a wide range of physical conditions that roughly corresponds to depths and strain rates calculated for instrumentally observed episodic tremor and slip (ETS) in presently-deforming subduction thrust interfaces. Stress cycling is accompanied by mixed brittle plastic-viscous deformation, and occurs as a consequence of geometric reorganisation and the progressive development and breakdown of stress bridges as blocks mutually obstruct one another. We argue that periods of low differential stress correspond to periods of rapid mixed-mode deformation and ETS. Stress cycling episodicities are a function of shear strain rate and pressure/temperature conditions at depth. The time period of stress cycling is principally controlled by the geometry (block distribution and density through time) and stress cycling amplitudes are controlled by effective stress. The duration of stress cycling events in the models (months-years) and rapid strain rates are comparable to instrumentally observed ETS. Shear strain rates are 1 – 2 orders of magnitude slower between stress cycling events, suggesting episodic return times within a single model domain are long duration (> centennial timescales), assuming constant flow stress. Finally, we derive a bulk viscous flow law for block dominated subduction mélanges for conditions 300 – 500°C and elevated pore fluid pressures. Bulk flow laws calculated for block-dominated subduction mélanges are non-linear, owing to a combination of non-linear matrix viscosity and development of tensile fractures at rapid shear strain rates. Model behaviour, including the generation of mixed-mode deformation, is highly comparable to the exhumed block-dominated melange found within the Chrystalls Beach Complex.