Strength of Wet and Dry Montmorillonite

Abstract:

Montmorillonite, an expandable smectite clay, is a common mineral in fault zones to a depth of around 3 km. Its low strength relative to other common fault gouge minerals is important in many models of fault rheology. However, the coefficient of friction is not well constrained in the literature due to the difficulty of establishing fully drained or fully dried states in the laboratory. For instance, in some reported studies, samples were either partially saturated or possibly over pressured, leading to wide variability in reported shear strength. In this study, the coefficient of friction, µ, of both saturated and oven-dried (at 150°C) Na-montmorillonite was measured at normal stresses up to 680 MPa at room temperature and shortening rates from 1.0 to 0.01 µm/s. Care was taken to shear saturated samples slowly enough to avoid pore fluid overpressure in the clay layers. Coefficients of friction are reported after 8 mm of axial displacement in a triaxial apparatus on saw-cut samples containing a layer of montmorillonite gouge, with either granite or sandstone driving blocks. For saturated samples, µ increased from around 0.1 at low pressure to 0.25 at the highest test pressures. In contrast, values for oven-dried samples decreased asymptotically from approximately 0.78 at 10 MPa normal stress to around 0.45 at 400-680 MPa. While wet and dry strengths approached each other with increasing effective normal stress, wet strength remained only about half of the dry strength at 600 MPa effective normal stress. The increased coefficient of friction can be correlated with a reduction in the number of loosely bound lubricating surface water layers on the clay platelets due to applied normal stress under saturated conditions.

The steady-state rate dependence of friction, a-b, was positive and dependent on normal stress. For saturated samples, a-b increased linearly with applied normal stress from ~0 to 0.004, while for dry samples a-b decreased with increasing normal stress from 0.008 to 0.002. All values were either neutral or rate strengthening, indicating a tendency for stable sliding.