Discrimination Between Clouds and Snow in Landsat 8 Imagery: an Assessment of Current Methods and a New Approach

Abstract:

Discrimination between snow and clouds poses a serious but tractable challenge to the consistent delivery of high-quality information on mountain snow from remote sensing. Clouds obstruct the surface from the sensor’s view, and the similar optical properties of clouds and snow make accurate discrimination difficult. We assess the performance of the current Landsat 8 operational snow and cloud mask products (LDCM CCA and CFmask), along with a new method, using over one million manually identified snow and clouds pixels in Landsat 8 scenes. The new method uses physically based scattering models to generate spectra in each Landsat 8 band, at that scene’s solar illumination, for snow and cloud particle sizes that cover the plausible range for each. The modeled spectra are compared to pixels’ spectra via several independent ways to identify snow and clouds. The results are synthesized to create a final snow/cloud mask, and the method can be applied to any multispectral imager with bands covering the visible, near-infrared, and shortwave-infrared regions. Each algorithm we tested misidentifies snow and clouds in both directions to varying degrees. We assess performance with measures of Precision, Recall, and the F statistic, which are based on counts of true and false positives and negatives. Tests for significance in differences between spectra in the measured and modeled values among incorrectly identified pixels help ascertain reasons for misidentification. A cloud mask specifically designed to separate snow from clouds is a valuable tool for those interested in remotely sensing snow cover. Given freely available remote sensing datasets and computational tools to feasibly process entire mission histories for an area of interest, enabling researchers to reliably identify and separate snow and clouds increases the usability of the data for hydrological and climatological studies.