Insight into He diffusion in apatite by ion beam experiments and quantum calculations: implication for the (U-Th)/He thermochronometer

Abstract:

The apatite (U–Th)/He (AHe) system has rapidly become a very popular thermochronometer, however, interpretation of AHe age depends on a precise knowledge of He diffusion. Several studies suggest that He retention is function of the amount of damage that is controlled by U–Th concentration, grain chemistry and thermal history. Still, the models are not well constrained and do not fully explain the mechanism of He retention.

In order to have a deeper insight into this issue, a multidisciplinary study on apatite combining physical methods such as multi-scale theoretical diffusion calculations based on Density Functional Theory (DFT) with diffusion experiments by ion beam Elastic Recoil Diffusion Analysis (ERDA) were performed. Quantum calculations permit to quantify He diffusivity base level for damage-free crystal and to estimate the additional energy cost to extract He atoms trapped in point defects (i.e. vacancies). On the other hand ion beam ERDA experiments allow to measure He diffusivity in artificially damaged crystals.

We show that damage-free apatite crystals are characterized by low retention behavior and closure temperature of ~35°C for pure F-apatite to higher value for Cl rich apatite (up to 12°C higher), for typical grain size and cooling rate (Mbongo-Djimbi et al., 2015). Our computed closure temperature is slightly lower than previously reported experimental values (~50°C). Using ERDA and DFT modeling of damage, we show how He diffusivity is influenced by damage. Finally, we are able to propose a new modeling of He diffusion incorporating mechanisms not included in classical damage models, and taking into account the level of damage and apatite chemistry. We show that it could affect significantly AHe age interpretation.

Mbongo-Djimbi D. et al. 2015. Apatite composition effect on (U-Th)/He thermochronometer: an atomistic point of view. Geohimica Cosmochim. Acta.