Neon isotopes show that Earth was accreted from irradiated material

Abstract:

Since the 1980s, the notion that the Earth’s mantle has a “solar” isotopic signature for neon has been favoured. Indeed, the 20Ne/22Ne ratio is above 12.5 in the mantle sources of OIB and MORB, close to the solar composition (13.4 for the Sun or 13.8 for the solar wind) and different from both atmospheric and chondritic compositions (Phase Q, Neon A). The most well accepted process invoked to explain this observed solar composition in the mantle is dissolution into a magma ocean of solar gases captured by gravity around the proto-Earth. However, Earth was accreted after gas from the proto-planetary disk had evaporated, suggesting that Earth itself could not have captured such a solar primordial atmosphere. Only planetary embryos were formed when the gas was still present in the disk. However, these planetary embryos with the mass of Mars are not massive enough to capture a solar dense atmosphere able to incorporate enough neon into the mantle. New estimates of the neon isotopic compositions of both the Earth’s mantle and of the implanted solar wind into grains suggest that the origin of the neon on Earth is related to solar wind irradiation on µm grains before planetary accretion started and not dissolution. Although incorporation of solar ions by this process is only significant for very volatiles (depleted) elements, the irradiation by x-rays has important consequences for the bulk chemistry of irradiated grains as it has been demonstrated that it produces depletion in Mg and Si, relatively to O (e.g Bradley et al., 1994), a pattern also observed for the Bulk silicate Earth.

References

Bradley, J. (1994). "Chemically Anomalous, Preaccretionally irradiated Grains in Interplanetary fust from Comets." Science 265: 925-929.