The Temperature of the Icelandic Mantle Plume from Aluminium-in-Olivine Thermometry

Abstract:

Temperature is a key control on the physical properties of the mantle, in particular the extent of melting during upwelling. It is not, however, a unique control on many of the parameters used to estimate mantle temperature. For example igneous crustal thickness which has often been used as a first-order proxy for mantle temperature, is also affected by mantle lithology and plume flux. Alternatives to geophysical indicators of mantle temperature are petrological thermometers. However, these record crystallisation temperatures, therefore a series of assumptions about the coupled melt- solid mantle thermal history must be made when calculating back to mantle potential temperature. In this study we investigate how these assumptions may affect mantle temperature estimates and how crystallisation temperatures may offer insights into the melting and melt transport processes, focussing on a new set of crystallisation temperature estimates we have made on primitive Icelandic basalts.

We used the aluminium-in-olivine thermometer of Coogan et al. (2014) to estimate crystallisation temperatures of olivine phenocrysts in a suite of samples from the Northern Volcanic Zone (NVZ) of Iceland. The data suggest that within a single volcanic system crystallisation temperature depends strongly on the olivine forsterite content, thus the history of melt evolution, and how the eruption samples this, must be considered when extrapolating to mantle temperature. To assess the influence of the assumptions required to obtain mantle temperature we constructed a simple thermal model incorporating varying proportions of lherzolite, pyroxenite and harzburgite undergoing decompression melting. A trade off between increasing mantle temperature and decreasing pyroxenite (or increasing harzburgite) in the source is observed. Using this dataset and our model, calculations reveal a potential temperature of 1470±130 °C for Iceland, and a temperature excess of 150±40 °C relative to ambient mantle. These estimates are consistent with temperatures estimated using crustal thickness and melt chemistry.