Discussion Starter: The Case for Duplexing without Channel Flow During the Development and Emplacement of the Himalayan Middle Crust

Abstract:

This presentation and another presentation led by Dawn Kellett will preface a ten-minute open discussion on how the Himalayan middle crust was developed and emplaced. Current hypotheses are transitioning from a set including wedge extrusion, channel flow with focused denudation, and tectonic wedging to a revised dichotomy: models with intense upper plate out-of-sequence activity (i.e., tunneling of channel flow, and critical taper wedge behavior) versus models in which the upper plate mainly records basal accretion of horses (i.e., duplexing). Critical taper and duplexing offer a simple contrast that can be illustrated via food analogies. If a wedge is critical, it churns internally like a pile of Cheerios^TM cereal pushed up an inclined plane. Stacking of a duplex acts like a deli meat-slicing machine: slice after slice is cut from the intact block to a stack of slices, but neither the block (~down-going plate) nor the stack (~upper plate) features much internal deformation. Thus critical taper and channel tunneling models predict much processing via out-of-sequence deformation, whereas duplexing predicts in-sequence thrusting. The two concepts may be considered end-members. Recent work shows that the Himalayan middle crust has been assembled along a series of mainly southwards-younging thrust faults. The thrust faults separate 1-5 km thick panels that experienced similar metamorphic cycles during different time periods. Out-of-sequence deformation is rare, with its apparent significance enhanced because of the high throw-to-heave ratio of out-of-sequence thrusting. Flattening fabrics developed prior to thrusting have been interpreted to record either (1) southwards channel tunneling across the upper plate, or (2) fabric development during metamorphism of the down-going plate. We will argue that the thrust faults dominantly represent in-sequence duplexing, and therefore conclude that the Himalaya and analogous hot orogens behave like other accretionary orogens.