Magnesium isotope compositions of Solar System materials determined by double spiking

Abstract:

As a major element, magnesium is of interest for investigating large scale processes governing the formation and evolution of rocky planetary bodies. Determining the Mg isotope composition of the Earth and other planetary bodies has hence been a topic of interest ever since mass-dependent fractionation of ‘non-traditional’ stable isotopes has been used to study high-temperature processes.

Published results, however, suffer from disagreement on the Mg isotope compositions of the Earth and chondrites [1-5], which is attributed to residual matrix effects. Nonetheless, most recent studied have converged towards a homogeneous (chondritic) Mg isotope composition in the Solar System [2-5].

However, in several of the recent studies there is a hint of a systematic difference of about 0.02-0.06‰ in the ²⁶Mg^/24Mg isotope compositions of chondrites and Earth. Such difference, however, is only resolvable by taking standard errors, which assumes robust data for homogenous sample sets. The discrepancies between various studies unfortunately undermine the confidence in such robustness and homogeneity.

The issues with matrix effects during isotopic analyses can be overcome by using a double spike approach. Such methodology generally requires three isotope ratios to solve for three unknowns, a requirement that cannot be met for Mg. However, using a newly developed approach, we present Mg isotope compositions obtained by critical mixture double spiking. This new approach should allow greater confidence in the robustness of the data and hence enable improvement of.

Preliminary data indicate that chondrites have a resolvable ~0.04‰ lighter ²⁶Mg/²⁴Mg than (ultra)mafic rocks from Earth, Mars and the eucrite parent body, which appear indistinguishable from each other. It seems implausible that this difference is caused by magmatic process such as partial melting or crystallisation. More likely, Mg isotopes are fractionated by a non-magmatic process during the formation of planets, e.g. by vapour-condensate fractionation.

[1] Wiechert and Halliday, 2007. EPSL 256, 360-371. [2] Bourdon et al., 2010. GCA 74, 5069-5083. [3] Teng et al., 2010. GCA 74, 4150-4166. [4] Chakrabarti and Jacobsen, 2010. EPSl 293, 349-358. [5] Von Strandmann, 2011. GCA 75, 5247-5268.