Fracture density and grain size controls on the relief structure of threshold landscapes

Abstract:

A central goal in geomorphology is to untangle the competing controls of climate, tectonics, and rock strength on the topography and relief structure of mountain ranges. This is important for deciphering the history of climate and tectonics encoded in landscapes, predicting natural hazards, and quantifying critical zone processes. Incorporating rock strength into landscape evolution models has been a particularly challenging problem, because the factors that determine rock strength vary in importance depending on process. Here we propose a mechanism of hillslope-channel coupling by which tectonically-induced fracturing influences the relief structure of steep, rocky “threshold” landscapes by leading to A) increased fracture density in exposed bedrock outcrops, thereby limiting hillslope relief, and B) decreased grain size of channel bed material, thereby reducing the magnitude of fluvial incision thresholds and increasing the erosional efficiency of bedrock rivers. To test this hypothesis, we compare two contrasting landscapes in southern California—the eastern San Gabriel Mountains and the northern San Jacinto Mountains. The eastern San Gabriel Mountains rise 2 km in relief and exhibit high uplift and erosion rates due to active faulting along the Cucamonga thrust fault. Although bedrock on hillslopes is common, the exposed granitic and metamorphic basement rock is highly fractured at the decimeter or finer scale, and river channels are mantled with a thin layer of gravel-cobble alluvium. The northern San Jacinto Mountains, 80 km to the southeast, experience similar mean runoff and daily runoff variability, and are underlain by similar bedrock. Yet, despite an absence of active faulting, and erosion rates slower than the eastern San Gabriel Mountains by a factor of 5, the northern San Jacinto Mountains preserve one of the steepest escarpments in the contiguous US (2-3 km high), characterized by massive bedrock outcrops on hillslopes with meter-scale or larger fracture spacing, and a resulting channel network mantled with large boulders. Preliminary analyses suggest that fracture spacing and bed material grain size in threshold landscapes are tightly coupled, and influence the steepness of hillslopes and channels that control the relief structure of mountain ranges in a predictable manner.