Late Impacts and the Origins of the Atmospheres on the Terrestrial Planets

Abstract:

Models for the origin of terrestrial atmospheres typically require an intricate sequence of events, including hydrodynamic escape, outgassing of mantle volatiles and late delivery. Here we discuss the origin of the atmospheres on the terrestrial planets in light of new ideas about the formation of the Moon, giant impact induced atmospheric loss and recent noble gas measurements.

Our new measurements indicate that noble gases in the Earth’s atmosphere cannot be derived from any combination of fractionation of a nebular-derived atmosphere followed by outgassing of deep or shallow mantle volatiles. While Ne in the mantle retains a nebular component, the present-day atmosphere has no memory of nebular gases. Rather, atmospheric noble gases have a close affinity to chondrites. On the other hand, Venus’s atmosphere has 20 and 70 times higher abundance of ²⁰Ne and ³⁶Ar, respectively, and a ²⁰Ne/²²Ne ratio closer to the solar value than Earth’s atmosphere. While the present atmosphere of Mars is significantly fractionated in the lighter noble gases due to long term atmospheric escape, the Kr isotopic ratios in Martian atmosphere are identical to solar. Thus, while Earth’s atmosphere has no memory of accretion of nebular gases, atmospheres on both Venus and Mars preserve at least a component of nebular gases.

To explain the above observations, we propose that a common set of processes operated on the terrestrial planets, and that their subsequent evolutionary divergence is simply explained by planetary size and the stochastic nature of giant impacts. We present geochemical observations and simulations of giant impacts to show that most of Earth’s mantle was degassed and the outgassed volatiles were largely lost during the final sequence of giant impacts onto Earth. Earth’s noble gases were therefore dominantly derived from late-accreting planetesimals. In contrast, Venus did not suffer substantial atmospheric loss by a late giant impact and retains a higher abundance of both nebular and chondritic noble gases compared to Earth. Fast-accreting Mars has a noble gas signature inherited from the solar nebula, and its low mass allowed for gravitational escape of the volatile components in late accreting planetesimals due to vaporization upon impact.