Isotope Effects Associated with N2O Production By Fungal and Bacterial Nitric Oxide Reductases: Implications for Tracing Microbial Production Pathways

Abstract:

Site preference (SP), the difference in δ¹⁵N between the central (α) and outer (β) N atoms in N₂O, has emerged as a conservative tracer of microbial N₂O production. The key advantages of SP relative to bulk isotopes are (1) that it is independent of the isotope composition of the substrates of nitrification and denitrification and (2) has not been shown to exhibit fractionation during production. In pure microbial culture distinct SP values for N₂O production from bacterial denitrification, including nitrifier-denitrification (-10 to 0 ‰), relative to hydroxylamine oxidation and fungal denitrification (33-37 ‰) provide a promising basis to resolve production pathways. In this study, we determined the δ¹⁵N, δ¹⁸O, δ¹⁵N^α, and δ¹⁵N^β of N₂O generated by purified fungal (P450nor) and bacterial nitric oxide reductases. The isotope values were used to calculate SP values, enrichment factors (e), and kinetic isotope effects (KIEs). Both O and N^α displayed normal isotope effects during enzymatic NO reduction by the P450nor with e values of -25.7‰ (KIE = 1.0264) and -12.6‰ (KIE = 1.0127), respectively. However, bulk nitrogen (average δ¹⁵N of N^α and N^β) and N^β exhibited inverse isotope effects with e values of 14.0‰ (KIE = 0.9862) and 36.1‰ (KIE = 0.9651), respectively. The observed inverse isotope effect in δ¹⁵N^β is consistent with reversible binding of the first NO in the P450nor reaction mechanism. Experiments with bacterial nitric oxide reductase are ongoing, however, preliminary data indicates a inverse isotope effect in the α and β positions and a normal isotope effect in δ¹⁸O. In contrast to the constant SP observed during N₂O production observed in microbial cultures, the SP measured for purified P450nor was not constant, increasing from ~15‰ to ~29‰ during the course of the reaction. Our results clearly indicate that fractionation of SP during N₂O production by P450nor is not zero, and that SP values higher and lower than the proposed end member value of 37‰ can be expected during fungal denitrification. The observation in pure microbial culture of constant SP can only be reconciled if the rate of nitrite and NO reduction are the same (thereby maintaining a steady NO concentration in the cell), and, further, that the magnitude of the P450nor NO binding constant (K_d) maintains the extent of the reaction (1-f) at 65%.