Experimental Constraints on Alkali Volatilization during Chondrule Formation: Implications for Early Solar System Heterogeneity

Abstract:

The chemical variability of chondrule volatile element contents provide a wealth of information on the processes that shaped the early solar system and its compositional heterogeneity. An essential observation is that chondrule melts contain very low alkalies and other volatile elements (e.g., Cl). The reason for this depletion is the combined effects of cooling rates (10 to 1000K/h), the small size of chondrules, and their high melting temperatures (~1700 to 2100 K) resulting in extensive loss of volatiles at canonical pressures (e.g., 10^-4bar). However, we observe some chondrules with significant concentrations of volatiles (Na, Cl), that differ markedly from chondrules dominated by refractory elements. Could such heterogeneity arise from loss of alkalis and Cl to a gas phase that itself later condenses, thereby yielding variations in volatile enrichments in chondrules? Does Cl enhance volatility of the alkalis to varying extents?

Experiments on Cl-bearing and Cl-free melts of equivalent composition for 10 min, 4 h, and 6 h reveal systematic effects of Cl on alkali volatility. Cl-bearing melts lose 48% of initial Na₂O, 66% of K₂O, 96% of Cl within the first 10 minutes of degassing. Then the amount of alkali loss decreases due to the absence of Cl. Cl-free melts loses only 15% of initial Na₂O and 33% K₂O. After 4 hours, melts lose 1/3 of initial Na₂O and 1/2 of K₂O. For both systems, Na₂O is more compatible in the melt relative to K₂O. Therefore, the vapor given off has a K/Na ratio higher than the melt through time in spite of the much higher initial Na abundance in the melt. Enhanced vaporization of alkalis from Cl-bearing melt suggests that Na and K evaporate more readily as volatile chlorides than as monatomic gases. Cl-free initial melts with normative plagioclase of An₅₀Ab₄₄Or₆ evolved into slightly normal zoned ones (An₄₉Ab₅₀Or₁) while Cl-bearing initial melts normative to albitic plagioclase (An₄₆Ab₅₀Or₄) evolved to reverse zoned ones (An₅₄Ab₄₅Or₁). The vapor phase over Cl-bearing chondrule melts may have a bimodal character over time. The heteregeneous volatile contents of chondrules may result from quenching of melt droplets at different stages of repeated heating, chondrule fragment recycling, and recondensation of exsolved volatiles.