Immobile Trace Element Discrimination of Near-cogenetic Eruptions

Abstract:

A chemical diagram to discriminate individual magma batches in composite plutonic/volcanic complexes is proposed here: x = Y/Al, y = Zr/Ti. Both ratios are stable during weathering and low-grade metamorphism. Y/Al only depends on fractional crystallization of garnet, xenotime and monazite during magmatogenesis and the degree of partial melting. This already distinguishes individual magmas. Zr/Ti is modified by other phases (rutile, titanite, zircon, ilmenite, biotite, etc) that neither accommodate nor fractionate trivalent cations and provides a totally independent perspective on magmatogenesis.

The Y/Al-Zr/Ti plot has no relation to tectonic setting (convergent, rift, intraplate, etc) and is not designed to distinguish lines of descent (calc-alkaline, transitional, etc). Instead, it can discriminate at a very fine scale lavas that share a common regional origin and are therefore confused in classic tectonic discrimination plots. Disentangling individual magma batches is inaccessible to global modeling but important to chronostratigraphers. Application to two well studied examples, Adamello (Alps) and North Anatolia, reproduces known consanguinity and rejects a few dubious ones.