Sulfide in the core and the composition of the silicate Earth

Abstract:

The chemical composition of the Earth is traditionally explained in terms of evolution from a solar-like composition, similar to that found in primitive ‘chondritic’ meteorites. It now appears, however, that the silicate Earth is not ‘chondritic’, but depleted in incompatible elements, including refractory lithophile and heat-producing elements. Either Earth lost material during planet-building due to collisional erosion or else internal differentiation processes produced a hidden reservoir deep in the early Earth.

Sulfide in the core may provide a reservoir capable of balancing the composition of the silicate Earth. Recent experimental work suggests that the core contains a significant proportion of sulfide, added during the final stages of accretion and new data suggests that at high pressures sulfide can incorporate a substantial amount of refractory lithophile and heat-producing elements [1]. Pioneering work using the short-lived ¹⁴⁶Sm-¹⁴²Nd system strongly suggests that Earth’s silicate mantle is non-chondritic [e.g. 2]. The drawback of such radiogenic isotope systems is that it is not possible to distinguish the fractionation of Sm/Nd that occurs during silicate melting from that occurring during the segregation of a sulfide-melt to form the core.

Neodymium stable isotopes have the potential to provide just such a tracer of sulfide segregation, because there is a significant contrast in bonding environment between sulfide and silicate, where heavy isotopes should be preferentially incorporated into high force-constant bonds involving REE³⁺ (i.e. the silicate mantle). Preliminary data indicate that mantle rocks do indeed possess heavier ¹⁴⁶Nd/¹⁴⁴Nd values than chondritic meteorites, consistent with the removal of light Nd into sulfide in the core, driving the residual mantle to heavy values. Overall, our isotope and elemental data indicate that the rare earths and other incompatible elements are substantially incorporated into sulfide. While Nd Stable isotope data for chondritic meteorites and mantle rocks, are consistent with the segregation of sulfide to the core.

[1] Wohlers &Wood, Nature 520, 337 (2015) [2] Boyet & Carlson, Science 309, 576 (2005)