Culture Bottle Investigations of Nutrient Enriched Oligotrophic Phytoplankton Communities Challenge Contemporary Beliefs

Humankind has fundamentally altered the global nitrogen cycle, such that today as much nitrogen is fixed from the atmosphere anthropogenically, as is fixed naturally by terrestrial and aquatic systems. 70% of this alteration is in the form of nitrogenous fertilizers, and Haber-Bosh production of urea now accounts for ~20% of total global nitrogen fixation (anthropogenic and natural).

Cultural eutrophication has long been implicated in an apparent increase in the number and severity of harmful algal blooms (HAB). More recently the form of introduced nitrogen has been receiving attention, with urea in particular singled out as a potential causative agent, yet this deduction seems to largely rely on observed correlations rather than establishment of a direct link. An alternative hypothesis is that environmental factors rather than the form of nitrogen exert a controlling influence on the nature of phytoplankton response to nutrient enrichment.

Here I present the results of a series of eight repeated experiments conducted over an annual cycle in 2013-2014 using oligotrophic coastal phytoplankton assemblages to asses the effect of urea and nitrate enrichment on size distribution, speciation, and biochemistry. Experiments were conducted at one location offshore Sydney, Australia but had very different oceanographic starting conditions. The result of enrichment (+8 μM N & +0.5 μM P) using both nitrate and urea was a greater abundance of diatoms than dinoflagellates in all cases. Overall species composition was not significantly different (at 0.05 level) for nitrate and urea as revealed by multidimensional scaling and permutational ANOVA. However in some cases, contrary to published speculation, nitrate rather than urea resulted in increased abundance of dinoflagellates. A generalized mixed modeling approach identified aspects of the water column which appear to be associated with the presence of the East Australian Current as being influential.

These results imply that greater caution should be applied when extrapolating observed correlations and laboratory measurements of individual cultured species to predict the reaction of planktonic communities to nutrient enrichment. Given that urea production is expected to double by 2050 understanding its influence in diverse marine environments is critical.