Shared Roles of Halobacteriovorax and Viruses in Bacterial Mortality: The Environment Dictates the Winner

Bacteriophages (phages) are considered to be a major contributor to bacterial mortality. Although recent evidence shows a similar role for the predatory bacterium, Halobacteriovorax (HBx), this organism has been largely ignored. We designed controlled laboratory microcosm studies to examine and compare the predation of a virus and an HBx strain on Vibrio vulnificus (Vv), under a range of environmental conditions. Predator-prey models were used to simulate the results and interpolated using Matlab software. The results show that although the HBx and virus both preyed on Vv, the magnitudes of their respective responses were different and were largely driven by environmental conditions. In low nutrient seawater, HBx was highly active in preying on Vv, resulting in a 4.4 log reduction of prey within 40 hours, whereas phage contributed little to bacterial mortality. However, when nutrients were added to the seawater, phage was the more active predator. At moderate levels of nutrient concentrations (DNB 1:10 and DNB 1:100) both predators were active. Both virus and HBx grew well at salt concentrations ranging from 9 to 30 ppt. Phage reproduction was optimized at 30 ppt and also occurred at higher levels at 40 and 45 ppt. HBx, on the other hand, grew best at 9 ppt and did not grow at 40 and 45 ppt. At temperatures between 15 and 37˚C both predators grew well. The impact of predation on Vv was positively correlated with temperature. The collective results of this study suggest that both HBx and phages can play significant roles in bacterial mortality and hence in shaping microbial communities and cycling nutrients. However, whether HBx or phages play the larger role in any circumstance may be orchestrated by environmental conditions. These results warrant reconsideration of the roles of different biological agents and the environment in bacteria mortality.