An Analysis of Fish Communities on Structured Habitat in the Northwestern Gulf of Mexico: Potential Impacts of "Rigs-to-Reefs" Programs and a Comparison with Natural Banks

Artificial habitat in the northwestern Gulf of Mexico is predominantly comprised of both active and reefed oil and gas platforms. In the last few decades, Texas alone has converted over 140 decommissioned oil and gas platforms into permitted artificial reefs. Despite the predominance of this habitat type, the associated fish communities remain poorly studied and few comparisons with natural habitat have been done. Using remotely operated vehicles in 2012 and 2013, we documented fish assemblages surrounding 15 artificial structures and several natural banks located on the Texas shelf. Artificial sites were variable in depth (30-84 m), number of structures, and vertical relief. Both structure type and relief influenced species richness and community structure at these sites. However, bottom depth was most influential with a shift in community composition and high diversity observed at approximately 60 m depth. In this same region, drowned coralgal reefs (the South Texas Banks) provide natural hard substrate with relief up to 20 m. Comparisons between these natural habitats and artificial reefs with similar depths and relief clearly demonstrate fish community differences, perhaps indicating differences in habitat function. To attain species-specific management goals, reefing programs should carefully consider the ambient environmental conditions (i.e., depth) and proximity of natural habitats, as these will most certainly affect the fish assemblage and characteristics of exploited fisheries species.