Net Ecosystem Calcification by a Coral Reef Community under Natural Acidification

Net Ecosystem Calcification (NEC) is a measure of the balance between calcium carbonate production (calcification) and loss (dissolution) within a coral reef system. Establishing baseline NEC estimates for a broad range of coral reef systems today provides much needed information to constrain spatial and temporal variability within and amongst different systems, investigate the sensitivity of ecosystem scale calcification to environmental forcing, and improve projections of coral reef futures under ocean acidification throughout this century. Previous NEC studies have been limited to coral reefs with unidirectional (Lagrangian and flow respirometry studies) or negligible (slack water Eulerian studies) water flow across the reef for at least part of the day, usually on the order of hours. Here, we present NEC rates in a naturally low pH, semi-enclosed coral reef lagoon with high coral cover and diversity and tidally driven flow within the Palau Rock Islands. NEC was determined from data collected over the full diel cycle for four consecutive days, during two successive years and different seasons, using total alkalinity (TA), salinity, and volume budgets. Two different methods used to calculate NEC are in good agreement and show that the coral community is net calcifying despite high rates of bioerosion and pH (mean pH = 7.88 ± 0.02) and aragonite saturation state (Ω_ar = 2.66 ± 0.11) levels close to those projected for the end of this century. Critically, NEC rates in year 1 (17.0 – 23.7 mmol m^-2 d^-1) were half those of year 2 (42.0 – 48.1 mmol m^-2 d^-1), though the carbonate chemistry of the source water did not change between years. This suggests that single occupations and short term measurements do not adequately capture the full range of NEC variability within a system and that factors other than ocean acidification play an important role in modulating NEC rates.