DNA barcoding reveals high diversity of deep-sea octocorals on Hawaiian seamounts

Globally, studies of deep-sea octocoral distribution and diversity have been hampered by a lack of keys and a plethora of unidentified specimens. Even in areas where intensive morphological work has been done, as many as half of the specimens remain unidentified to species or even genus. Recently, a suite of genetic markers have been identified as barcoding proxies for octocorals. Here, we make one of the first attempts at broad-scale application of 3 of these markers, to recent and museum collections of octocorals of approximately 1000 specimens from the Hawaiian Archipelago, to gain a better understanding of the diversity and distribution of deep-sea octocorals there. Sequence results for all 3 markers show a greater number of haplotypes than morphological species. Each of these markers as taken alone has been shown to underestimate species richness. Extrapolating from this we show that morphological work to date on these specimens underestimates species richness by 30-40%, suggesting the diversity of octocorals in the Hawaiian Archipelago is substantially greater than previously thought. The large percentage of haplotypes represented by single individuals suggests that the full diversity of deep-sea octocorals in Hawaii remains drastically undersampled. This work also shows that species ranges based on current species designations are overestimated, with multiple smaller-range haplotypes for given morphological operational taxonomic units. We evaluate these results to assess the usefulness of application of these markers to understanding deep-sea coral distributions in the broader Pacific and beyond.