Consistency of Bottom Fish Communities in the Beaufort Sea Within and Between Years

Fish communities in the Arctic may be indicators of change due to climate and oil and gas exploration. An initial benchmark is generally established by sampling a set of sites in multiple years sequentially to estimate interannual variability. Standard practice is to conduct one trawl haul per station. Establishing the annual frequency of sampling and minimum number of hauls per station necessary to detect changes in demersal fish communities is essential to designing a monitoring program. Using small bottom trawls, we assessed interannual variability of bottom fish communities between 2013 and 2014 in the eastern US Beaufort Sea at eight depths 20–1000 m on each of four transects. In 2014, to determine if one haul per station was representative of a site, replicate hauls were made at stations along one transect at the US–Canada border. The similarity among replicate hauls within a single year was excellent, indicating that one haul per station was representative of fish communities. There were distinctly different bottom fish communities on the Beaufort Sea shelf (20–100 m) and slope (200–1000 m). Shelf communities had higher abundances of smaller fishes; whereas slope communities had fewer, but larger, individuals. There was no change in fish abundance between years, but there was interannual variability in the biomass of fish communities on the slope. However, as few fishes were captured at deep stations, the difference between catching and not catching a single large heavy fish affected relative biomass significantly, which may distort the conclusion of interannual variability. Furthermore, these replicate hauls occurred in the eastern Beaufort Sea, which appears to have fewer fish species and in lower abundance than the western Beaufort Sea. The similarity within replicates may not be as striking in a more diverse environment, however this study shows that in this region of the Arctic, it is likely sufficient to forego replicate sampling at a station in one year and season, and sequential years of sampling in that season, when characterizing bottom fish communities within a long-term study of community stability.